The St. Louis Cardinals and Cincinnati Reds square off for a critical National League Central showdown on Saturday, May 23, 2026. After Friday night’s series opener was postponed, these division rivals will clash in a high-stakes split doubleheader at Great American Ball Park.
Game 1 features a fascinating pitching matchup that heavily favors the offenses. If you are looking to find an edge on the diamond, here is a breakdown of the starting pitchers and the best gambling bets for this early afternoon contest.
Starting Pitcher Analysis: Pallante vs. Paddack
The St. Louis Cardinals hand the ball to right-hander Andre Pallante (4-4, 4.04 ERA). Pallante has been the definition of a mixed bag this season. While he possesses excellent groundball utility, his tendency to pitch to contact can be incredibly dangerous in a hitter-friendly stadium. He will need sharp command of his breaking stuff to keep a disciplined Cincinnati lineup off balance.
The Cincinnati Reds counter with right-hander Chris Paddack (0-5, 7.07 ERA). To say it has been a brutal campaign for Paddack would be an understatement. He enters this weekend still searching for his first victory of 2026, plagued by an elevated hard-hit percentage and a ballooned ERA. While his underlying metrics suggest he is due for minor positive regression, trusting him to suddenly shut down a patient Cardinals offense is a massive gamble.
Best Bet: Over 9 Total Runs
When look at the pitching matchup alongside the offensive capabilities of both clubs, the over is the most enticing bet on the board. Great American Ball Park is notorious for yielding home runs, and neither starting pitcher inspires a ton of confidence right now.
Paddack’s struggles are well-documented, and the Cardinals have enough pop in the middle of their order to exploit his command issues early. On the flip side, the Reds feature an athletic lineup capable of manufacturing runs via the long ball and aggressive base running. Expect both teams to trade punches, making the Over a premier choice for Game 1.
Moneyline Pick: St. Louis Cardinals
With the moneyline odds sitting tightly in a near pick-em scenario, the value lies with the road team. St. Louis holds a distinct advantage in the starting pitching department. While Pallante has his flaws, he has shown a much higher floor this season than Paddack.
Doubleheaders often strain bullpens, but the team that can get 5 to 6 steady innings from its starter usually holds the upper hand. Back the Cardinals moneyline to capture the first leg of this twin bill.
Top Prop Bet: Cardinals First Five Innings (F5) Over
Because bullpen usage in the first game of a doubleheader can be highly unpredictable, isolating Chris Paddack is a sharp strategy. Rather than betting on the full game, take the Cardinals First Five Innings Team Total Over. St. Louis should waste no time getting to a struggling starter who has routinely given up early runs all season long.
Baseball Best Bets 