The Cincinnati Reds (17–14) and Pittsburgh Pirates (17–16) wrap up their divisional series at PNC Park on Sunday, May 3, 2026. With both teams jostling for position in a crowded NL Central, this series finale serves as a critical early-season litmus test. The matchup features a battle between a high-priced veteran ace looking to justify his contract and a hard-throwing right-hander aiming to stabilize a Cincinnati rotation decimated by injuries.

The Pitching Breakdown

Corbin Burnes (PIT): The Pirates made waves this past offseason by securing Corbin Burnes to lead their young staff. The former Cy Young winner enters Sunday with a 3–2 record and a 2.88 ERA through his first month in Pittsburgh. Burnes has been the epitome of a “workhorse,” averaging over six innings per start while maintaining a surgical 1.05 WHIP. His most recent outing on April 27 was a statement performance, as he dismantled the Cubs over seven frames, allowing just one run and racking up nine strikeouts. Burnes’ primary weapon—his devastating cutter—has limited opponents to a .198 batting average this spring. For the Pirates, Burnes represents the “stopper” mentality needed to close out series and keep the bullpen rested.

Graham Ashcraft (CIN): The Reds counter with Graham Ashcraft, who has found himself in a pivotal role following long-term injuries to Hunter Greene and Nick Lodolo. Ashcraft currently sports a 3.95 ERA and a 1.35 WHIP. While he hasn’t been as dominant as Burnes, Ashcraft has shown remarkable resilience; he is coming off a gritty win on April 28 where he navigated deep counts to provide six solid innings. Ashcraft relies on a high-velocity sinker and slider combination that generates a high volume of ground balls (52% rate). Against a Pirates lineup that has shown vulnerability to power-righties, Ashcraft’s ability to avoid the “big inning” will be the deciding factor for Cincinnati.

---

Strategic Best Bets

1. Pittsburgh Pirates Moneyline (-145) The pitching edge sits squarely with the home team. Corbin Burnes is currently pitching at an All-Star level, and the Pirates have won four of his six starts this season. While the Reds have been scrappy, their lineup ranks in the bottom third of the league in OPS against elite cutters. With Burnes on the mound and a Pirates bullpen that has been elite at home, Pittsburgh is the tactical choice to secure the series finale.

2. Under 8.5 Total Runs (-115) PNC Park remains one of the premier pitcher’s parks in the National League, and Sunday afternoon games often favor the arms. With Burnes limiting traffic on the bases and Ashcraft’s high ground-ball rate, the potential for a high-scoring blowout is low. Both teams have trended toward the under in their last five divisional matchups, making a 4–2 or 5–1 final score the most likely trajectory.

3. Corbin Burnes Over 6.5 Strikeouts (-110) Burnes has cleared this mark in four of his last five starts, including his nine-strikeout gem earlier this week. The Reds’ lineup, while aggressive, features several young hitters who struggle with Burnes’ late-moving breaking stuff. As long as he reaches his typical 95-pitch threshold, his “stuff” should carry him comfortably past this total.

---

The Sharp Edge: Watch Elly De La Cruz. The Reds’ shortstop has been the most consistent offensive force for Cincinnati, but he has historically struggled against high-velocity cutters. If Burnes establishes his primary pitch early, look for De La Cruz to struggle, but if Oneil Cruz finds a hanging slider from Ashcraft, he is the prime candidate for an “Over 1.5 Total Bases” prop win.