The best betting strategy for the MLB All-Star Game relies on targeting the National League moneyline and betting the under on total runs. Because top-tier pitchers only throw one or two innings at maximum velocity, games have heavily favored pitching dominance.

The Midsummer Classic is historically a showcase for elite bullpens and blazing fastballs, putting a damper on overall offensive production. Let’s break down why these are the smartest plays on the board and how you can maximize your payouts this summer.

Target the National League Moneyline
Historically, the American League dominated this exhibition event for over a decade. However, the tide has shifted, and the National League roster has built a distinct advantage in both raw power and pitching depth. When handicapping the moneyline, look for the National League to be listed around -135 odds at most regulated operators. The NL boasts dominant starters like Paul Skenes and heavy hitters including Shohei Ohtani and Bryce Harper. Because the American League’s cause can often be skewed by fan voting filling up rosters, the National League consistently profiles as the deeper, more well-rounded team. Siding with the NL on the moneyline provides the best baseline value, particularly when the odds hover right around the -134 to -135 mark.

Bet the Under on Total Runs
The under on total runs—typically set around 7.5—is one of the most reliable betting angles in modern baseball exhibitions. While casual fans tune in hoping for a high-scoring slugfest, the reality of the All-Star Game is that managers use a revolving door of elite relief pitchers. These hurlers are fully rested, throwing maximum-effort fastballs and devastating breaking pitches for just three to six outs apiece. Hitters struggle to time up four to five different pitchers with 100 mph fastballs in a single night. This rapid-fire substitution and elite pitching pipeline consistently suppress the offensive output. Taking the under on a 7.5 total run line is an incredibly solid wager.

Value in Player Props
If you want to sprinkle some action on individual player props, look for designated hitters or established veterans to record a base hit. Heavy hitters like Kyle Schwarber or Juan Soto offer excellent plus-money odds (+130 or higher) just to notch a single hit. These players often get multiple at-bats against different relievers, and they are fully capable of catching a mistake pitch over the plate. Combining the National League moneyline, the game under, and a star player to log a hit can result in a highly profitable same-game parlay.

As always, when placing your wagers, be sure to compare the odds across top-tier platforms. Whether you are placing a wager on a moneyline or building a parlay, you can lock in your bets on major regulated sportsbooks like FanDuel or DraftKings for competitive lines and available promotions.